Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery

Christopher T a month ago

Stopped by to get some pie to go. Been here before and it has been awhile since then. Parking can be hectic since small parking lot surround by office buildings, and nearby the Discovery Cube OC so plenty of foots traffic here. The restaurant is abit bigger than the other places but the bakery area is smaller. Staff seem worm-out and restless but trying his best to be cheerful. He’s nice though and I changed my order couple times and he seems to go along with it. The pies here are good but abit sweet for my taste by sometime I got sugar rush so perfect to fix that. Prices wise, okey not bad at all. Got cookies and muffins as well, big and good (still sweet, the American sweet that is). Overall not bad and got my sweet tooth craving fix for sure.

Mary Rizzaro 2 months ago

Cannot beat Pollys. Great place! Bring the kids! Bring everyone. The very best. Save room for pie. The crust- flaky and perfection, the fillings- Always an explosion of delectable flavor. Instant gratification if ever there was heaven on earth...this is it!!!

L AMC 2 months ago

The server Cezzane was so accommodating and friendly! He made us a fresh Banberry pie when they were all sold out! He was everything a Polly’s Pie employee should be. He made our visit very special and we WILL be back!

Carrie Robles 5 months ago

If you aren't going to Bingo Wednesday with Kyle, then you sure are missing out on a lot of fun! They have 2 sessions - 4-5:30pm and 7-8:30pm. You play about 5 or 6 games and can win all sorts of delicious Polly's baked treats, plus you have a chance to answer fun trivia questions. Kyle makes it a lot of fun! The word is definitely out, so the restaurant gets pretty full...so be sure to get there early for a table. We met some friends last night for the early game, and my hubby and I shared a sourdough burger - which I don't recommend as a shared meal. The patty is much smaller than the bread, so when it was cut in half, most of the meat patty was on one half of the sandwich, and the rest was on the other half. I got the half with the 1/4 of the patty, so my sandwich was mostly bread with lettuce and tomato and a tiny piece of meat. We got our burger with fries plus we added a side of onion rings - they were pretty good. I would rate the sandwich 3 stars, but I added an extra star for the fun Bingo!

Fritzgerald Kinney 6 months ago

Karina was really friendly and helpful. Our meals were extremely satisfying, the Comeback Chicken is trend worthy and the Classic Polly's Burger juicy, meaty and tasty. Beer battered onion rings are the way to go. No room for a pie this time, but well worth the trip just for a slice or whole pie.